Expertise Form

  • Share:

Expertise form of CJCP is an .doc file for reviewers to fill their comments. 

At the front of the form there is some contact information of the Editorial Office, and several blanks for Manuscript No, Title of Paper, Author(s) name, Referee name.

After filling those blanks, the reviewer should choose one of the "RECOMMENDATIONS" for the final decision.

Then, there is an text area for "GENERAL COMMENTS / SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS". The reviewer is also requested to choose one of the letters from A to E to evaluate the manuscript quality.

If the reviewer have some "COMMENTS FOR THE EDITOR ONLY, NOT TO BE RELAYED TO AUTHOR(S)", he/she can fill his/her comments separately under the sign of "COMMENTS FOR THE EDITOR ONLY" and "COMMENTS TO BE RELAYED TO AUTHOR".

  • Share: