%0 Journal Article
%T Comparison of Accuracy and Convergence Rate between Equilibrium and Nonequilibrium Alchemical Transformations for Calculation of Relative Binding Free Energy
%A Peng fei Li
%A Xiang yu Jia
%A Mei ting Wang
%A Ye Mei
%J Chinese Journal Of Chemical Physics
%@ 1003-7713
%V 30
%N 6
%D 2017
%P 789-799
%K Free energy;Equilibrium;Nonequilibrium;Convergence rate;Accuracy
%X Estimation of protein-ligand binding affinity within chemical accuracy is one of the grand challenges in structure-based rational drug design. With the efforts over three decades, free energy methods based on equilibrium molecular dynamics (MD) simulations have become mature and are nowadays routinely applied in the community of computational chemistry. On the contrary, nonequilibrium MD simulation methods have attracted less attention, despite their underlying rigor in mathematics and potential advantage in efficiency. In this work, the equilibrium and nonequilibrium simulation methods are compared in terms of accuracy and convergence rate in the calculations of relative binding free energies. The proteins studied are T4-lysozyme mutant L99A and COX-2. For each protein, two ligands are studied. The results show that the nonequilibrium simulation method can be competitively as accurate as the equilibrium method, and the former is more efficient than the latter by considering the convergence rate with respect to the cost of wall clock time. In addition, Bennett acceptance ratio, which is a bidirectional post-processing method, converges faster than the unidirectional Jarzynski equality for the nonequilibrium simulations.
%R 10.1063/1674-0068/30/cjcp1711204
%U http://cjcp.ustc.edu.cn/hxwlxb_en/ch/reader/view_abstract.aspx
%1 JIS Version 3.0.0